top of page

Stay As You Are, Or Make A Change? Let A Projection Guide You.

Nov 4
3 min read

By David Meffert,  Founder and Private Wealth Adviser at Linea Private Wealth


Should we sell? Should we change schools? Should we keep going as we are, or adjust something?


David Meffert, founder and senior adviser, Linea Private Wealth Melbourne

Yesterday the Reserve Bank raised the cash rate by 0.25 basis points to 4.85%. For many families that means higher mortgage repayments, at a time when school fees, insurance and everyday costs have already gone up.



Our advisers hear these questions most weeks, and after yesterday's decision we expect to hear them more often.

"A lot of people made big commitments a few years ago, when rates were much lower," says David Meffert, Founder and Private Wealth Adviser at Linea Private Wealth.

"The house, the school, the investment property. Now they're asking whether those still fit, and that's a fair thing to ask."


Staying Put Is A Decision Too.

Often the choice that feels safest is to leave things as they are. David thinks that choice should get the same scrutiny as a change.


"People tend to test the change and assume the current setup is fine," he says. "Keeping things as they are has costs too. We put every option through the same test." That test is a projection. Here's how we build one with clients.


  • We put your whole position down. Everything you own: your home, any investment property, super, shares, cash, a business. Everything you owe: mortgages, loans, credit cards. And every regular commitment: school fees, insurance, living costs. All of it in one place.

  • We project the cash flow. What's coming in over the next five, ten and twenty years, and what's going out, with realistic increases built in on both sides.

  • We project the assets and liabilities under each option. Keep the property or sell it. Stay at the current school or change. Keep going as you are or adjust something. Each option gets its own line.


Melbourne family at home weighing whether to sell, change schools or stay as they are

We look at two timeframes. First, your cash flow today: can you comfortably meet your commitments month to month? Then your retirement: does this choice move your retirement date, or change what retirement looks like?

"You need both," David says. "A plan that works for next year can look very different at 65."


Case Study: One Family, Three Options.

This example is illustrative. The names and figures are made up, but we see this situation often.


Sam and Priya are in their mid-40s with two children, aged 12 and 15, at an independent school. Fees run to about $40,000 a year per child. They have a $1.2 million home loan and an investment apartment worth around $650,000, with $500,000 still owing on it.


Each rate rise added to their repayments, and the monthly surplus they used to rely on had almost gone. They came in assuming the school would have to change.


We projected three options.

  1. Keep everything as it is. Cash flow would run short in some months until the younger child finishes school in six years, with savings covering the gap. Their target retirement age moved from 60 to around 63.

  2. Move the younger child to a different school. Cash flow improved straight away and retirement stayed close to 60. This was the option they least wanted.

  3. Sell the investment apartment. This cleared the $500,000 loan. They would give up the rental income and any future growth on the property, and capital gains tax would apply to the sale. Cash flow became comfortable and retirement landed at around 61.


They chose to sell the apartment.

"They'd walked in thinking the school had to go," David says. "Once they saw the options side by side, the apartment was the easier thing to let go of, and the kids stayed where they were."


What A Projection Gives You.

Sometimes the projection shows your current strategy is the right one, and you can stop second-guessing it. Sometimes it shows the strategy needs to change. Finding that out early gives you time to adjust.


Chart comparing three options for a family’s cash flow and retirement age after a rate rise

Either way, you leave with a clear picture of your options and what each one means for you and your family.


"This is a big part of what we do," David says. "Most people don't need a dramatic change. They need to see the numbers clearly enough to make the call with confidence."


Your first step this week: get everything you own, owe and pay onto one page. If you'd like us to build the projection with you, including what it means for your retirement, you can book a time with David here


This advice is general in nature and does not take into account your objectives, financial situation or needs. You should consider whether the advice is suitable for you and your personal circumstances.

bottom of page